If you’re looking for a used car under $9,000 that won’t make you dread long highway drives, you’re in the right place. I’ve put together a list of fuel-efficient cars that hit at least 35 MPG on the highway, are easy to maintain, and are actually findable in today’s used market without breaking your budget.
These are practical choices if you’re commuting, road-tripping, or just trying to cut back on gas expenses in 2025.
Why 35+ MPG Matters
While hybrids and EVs are becoming more common, there’s still huge value in efficient gas-powered or hybrid cars that don’t need a plug. Cars that get 35 MPG or more on the highway often mean fewer fill-ups, lower emissions, and more money left in your wallet each month.
Best Used Cars with 35+ MPG Highway Under $9,000
1. 2012–2015 Honda Civic
- Highway MPG: Up to 41
- Average Price (2025): $6,500 – $8,500
- Why It’s Worth It:
Honda’s legendary reliability and a smooth ride make this a top pick. Look for the HF trim for max fuel economy without sacrificing power. Easy to find, cheap to insure, and still modern inside.
2. 2013–2016 Hyundai Elantra
- Highway MPG: 38
- Average Price (2025): $5,500 – $7,500
- Why It’s Worth It:
Often overlooked, the Elantra gives you great MPG, a roomy interior, and a surprisingly refined design. You can usually find one with low mileage in this budget. Maintenance is also inexpensive.
3. 2012–2014 Toyota Corolla LE
- Highway MPG: 40
- Average Price (2025): $6,800 – $8,800
- Why It’s Worth It:
This one checks all the boxes: it’s reliable, affordable, and incredibly efficient. The LE Eco trim gets the best mileage thanks to its low-rolling-resistance tires and tweaked engine programming.
4. 2010–2013 Ford Fiesta
- Highway MPG: Up to 40
- Average Price (2025): $4,500 – $6,500
- Why It’s Worth It:
If you’re okay with a smaller ride, the Fiesta SFE is nimble, great on gas, and fun to drive. Manual versions get even better economy, and the interior tech is decent for the price point.
5. 2010–2012 Toyota Prius
- Highway MPG: 48
- Average Price (2025): $5,000 – $8,500
- Why It’s Worth It:
Yes, it’s a hybrid—but it’s also one of the most bulletproof used cars on the market. The Gen 3 Prius gives you insane gas mileage, tons of cargo space, and a very quiet drive. Plus, parts are everywhere and inexpensive.
6. 2013–2015 Mazda3
- Highway MPG: Up to 41
- Average Price (2025): $7,000 – $9,000
- Why It’s Worth It:
If you want driving fun and good MPG, the Mazda3 delivers. The Skyactiv engine technology is efficient without being underpowered, and the styling still looks fresh.
7. 2012–2015 Chevrolet Sonic
- Highway MPG: Up to 40
- Average Price (2025): $4,000 – $6,500
- Why It’s Worth It:
With a turbocharged engine and compact design, the Sonic is perfect for city and highway. It’s zippy and still manages solid fuel economy. Go for the manual if you want better control and higher MPGs.
Comparison Chart
| Model | Highway MPG | Price (2025) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Honda Civic (HF or LX) | Up to 41 | $6.5K – $8.5K | Reliable, refined ride |
| Hyundai Elantra | 38 | $5.5K – $7.5K | Underrated value |
| Toyota Corolla LE Eco | 40 | $6.8K – $8.8K | Built to last, efficient trim |
| Ford Fiesta SFE | Up to 40 | $4.5K – $6.5K | Small, agile, affordable |
| Toyota Prius (Gen 3) | 48 | $5K – $8.5K | Best MPG, hybrid reliability |
| Mazda3 Skyactiv | Up to 41 | $7K – $9K | Sporty, efficient |
| Chevy Sonic 1.4T (Manual) | Up to 40 | $4K – $6.5K | Budget-friendly and peppy |
Tips Before You Buy
- Avoid Flood/Salvage Titles: Always check the car history. Use Carfax or AutoCheck.
- Watch for CVT Issues: Some models (especially early Nissan Sentras or Rogues) are known for weak CVTs.
- Check Tire Quality: Bad tires can mess with your actual MPG by 2–4 MPG.
- Get a Pre-Purchase Inspection: $100 upfront could save you thousands.
You Might Also Like
- Top Fuel-Efficient Cars for City Driving Under $10,000
- Best Used Hybrids Under $8,000 Worth Buying in 2025
- Most Reliable Used Sedans Under $6,000 for Gas Mileage
Final Thoughts
You don’t need to spend big to get great highway fuel economy. If you’re patient, smart, and stick to well-known models like the Civic, Corolla, or Prius, you’ll find something that saves money every single mile.
Personally, I’d go with the Mazda3 or Prius if you want a balance of fun, tech, and long-term value—but every model on this list is a solid choice for budget-conscious drivers in 2025.