Best Subcompact Cars with High MPG and Low Maintenance Costs (Real Picks for 2025)

If you’re like me, you want a car that’s cheap to keep, easy to park, and doesn’t drain your wallet at the gas station or the mechanic. That’s where subcompact cars shine. They’re underrated in a world obsessed with trucks and SUVs, but if you’re driving mostly in the city or just want a commuter that won’t nag you with repair bills, these are the smartest choices for 2025.

I focused on cars that are still available either new or used (and still reliable), get excellent real-world fuel economy, and don’t require fancy tools or dealer-only service for every little thing.


🚗 1. 2024–2025 Mitsubishi Mirage

  • MPG: ~36 city / 43 highway
  • Why it’s great: It’s still the most fuel-efficient non-hybrid gas car in America. Super basic, but comes with a 10-year/100,000-mile powertrain warranty. Plus, the 3-cylinder engine is simple and easy to maintain.
  • Maintenance: Cheap parts, long intervals, easy DIY for brakes, filters, and oil.

🚗 2. 2016–2020 Honda Fit

  • MPG: ~33 city / 40 highway
  • Why it’s great: This car is famous for being like a TARDIS—tiny outside, roomy inside. It’s also built like a tank. Even at 100,000+ miles, Fits are usually still going strong with basic maintenance.
  • Maintenance: Affordable, straightforward, and there’s a huge online community for DIY fixes.

🚗 3. 2021–2023 Toyota Yaris (or Mazda2 in Canada/Europe)

  • MPG: ~32 city / 40 highway
  • Why it’s great: After Toyota rebadged the Mazda2 as the Yaris, it became one of the best-handling and most reliable subcompacts. The Skyactiv engine gets great MPG without hybrid complexity.
  • Maintenance: Mazda mechanics love this drivetrain—low failure rates and easy servicing.

🚗 4. 2017–2020 Kia Rio

  • MPG: ~33 city / 41 highway
  • Why it’s great: It’s not flashy, but it’s super dependable and easy to drive. If you get one with a manual, it’s even more fun. 2020 and earlier models have basic engines and simple tech.
  • Maintenance: Cheap brakes, filters, and even timing chains in later models. Parts are widely available.

🚗 5. 2017–2022 Chevrolet Spark

  • MPG: ~30 city / 38 highway
  • Why it’s great: You can usually find a used Spark for under $10,000 with low miles. The drivetrain is basic, the cabin is tiny but functional, and if you’re just using it to get around town, it’s a steal.
  • Maintenance: Very low parts cost, especially for brakes, suspension, and spark plugs. Repairs are simple if you don’t mind tight engine bays.

🚗 6. 2019–2022 Hyundai Accent

  • MPG: ~33 city / 41 highway
  • Why it’s great: Quiet, smooth ride, solid MPG, and still comes with Hyundai’s generous warranty if it’s a CPO.
  • Maintenance: Timing chains (not belts), common parts, and minimal electronics keep costs low.

🚗 7. 2016–2019 Nissan Versa Note

  • MPG: ~31 city / 39 highway
  • Why it’s great: While earlier Versas had issues, the Note hatchback offers decent MPG and a roomy back seat for the size. It’s no-frills, but that’s part of the appeal.
  • Maintenance: Reliable if you avoid the CVT issues by sticking with manual or lower-mileage examples. Maintenance is cheap and simple.

🛠️ What Makes These Subcompacts So Affordable?

  • Fewer cylinders = fewer repairs
  • Lightweight cars wear tires, brakes, and suspension more slowly
  • Smaller oil pans, cheaper tires, and lower insurance rates
  • Simple tech = fewer screen replacements or broken sensors

🔍 Comparison Table

ModelMPG (City/Hwy)Years to TargetNotable StrengthsAvg. Maintenance Cost
Mitsubishi Mirage36 / 432022–2025Warranty, MPGVery low
Honda Fit33 / 402016–2020Space, reliabilityLow
Toyota Yaris (Mazda2)32 / 402020–2023Fun to drive, durableLow
Kia Rio33 / 412017–2020Quiet, smooth rideLow
Chevrolet Spark30 / 382017–2022Dirt cheap usedVery low
Hyundai Accent33 / 412019–2022Modern interior, MPGLow
Nissan Versa Note31 / 392016–2019Roomy, basicLow to medium

Final Thoughts

Subcompacts aren’t just budget beaters anymore. Many of these cars deliver excellent fuel economy, offer practical cargo space, and cost very little to maintain. Personally, I’d go for a Honda Fit if you want versatility and reliability, or a Mitsubishi Mirage if you’re focused purely on gas mileage and low ownership cost.

If you want something newer and with a warranty, the Hyundai Accent is tough to beat. And for those who just want the absolute cheapest ride that won’t fall apart, you can probably find a decent Chevy Spark or Kia Rio for under $9,000.


Related Reads:

Let’s Talk Cars

Have a question? A suggestion? Just want to say hi?
You’re in the right place.

Use the form below to reach out to the AutoSpecs Daily team. We're happy to hear from readers, car lovers, first-time buyers, and anyone who's got something to share.

What can you contact us about?

  • Feedback on one of our articles
  • Ideas for new topics you'd like us to cover
  • Questions about cars, gear, or general auto advice
  • Media, partnership, or brand inquiries
  • Anything else that's on your mind

We check every message that comes through and do our best to respond within 2 to 3 business days.

We don’t list an email address here to avoid spam, but the contact form is the best and fastest way to reach us.

Thanks for stopping by. We're glad you're here.

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
Name