If you’re looking for a reliable used car with great fuel economy under $9,000, Mazda has a few hidden gems worth considering. I’ve personally dug through listings, owner reviews, and EPA ratings to find the models that deliver on both efficiency and long-term reliability without breaking the bank.
Why Consider Mazda?
Mazdas tend to fly under the radar compared to Toyota and Honda, but they’re some of the most enjoyable small cars to drive—often offering better handling and design than competitors. They’re also fairly easy to maintain, which is a big win when you’re trying to stay on budget.
1. Mazda3 (2012–2013)
- MPG: Up to 40 highway with Skyactiv engine
- What I Like: Fun to drive, great seats, refined interior for the price
- What to Watch For: Check suspension and engine mounts on higher mileage units
The 2012–2013 Mazda3 with the Skyactiv engine is a standout. Not only can it get close to 40 MPG on the highway, but it’s also more engaging to drive than most economy cars. The hatchback version is especially practical if you want cargo flexibility.
2. Mazda2 (2011–2014)
- MPG: 29 city / 35 highway
- What I Like: Simple, lightweight, and nimble in tight city streets
- What to Watch For: Limited features, and acceleration is modest
If you’re just commuting or running errands around town, the Mazda2 is an underrated pick. It’s not a powerhouse, but it’s ultra easy to park and very light on fuel. Just be sure you’re okay with basic features—this one was built for function, not flash.
3. Mazda6 (2010–2013)
- MPG: Around 30 highway
- What I Like: Roomy for long drives, more refined than a typical economy car
- What to Watch For: Automatic transmission issues in earlier models
If you need a midsize sedan for more space or family trips, the Mazda6 gives you a larger footprint while still offering decent gas mileage. You’ll find more of these in good condition compared to older Accords or Camrys in the same price range.
4. Mazda Tribute (2008–2010 Hybrid)
- MPG: Around 32 city / 28 highway
- What I Like: One of the few hybrid SUVs under $9k
- What to Watch For: These were co-developed with Ford—make sure hybrid battery is in good health
While the Tribute hybrid wasn’t a big hit when new, it’s a hidden option for people who want SUV space but don’t want to suffer at the pump. They’re rare, but if you find one that’s been well cared for, it can be a smart pick.
Reliability and Maintenance
Most of these Mazdas hold up well over time, especially if they’ve had regular oil changes and basic care. Parts are generally affordable, and you won’t have to visit a specialist mechanic. That said, it’s worth paying for a pre-purchase inspection on any used car, especially one with over 100k miles.
Who These Cars Are Great For
- College students and commuters who want solid MPG
- First-time buyers looking for something fun but reliable
- Anyone who values a responsive driving experience over just “point A to point B”
Final Thoughts
Used Mazdas under $9,000 are some of the best-kept secrets if you want great gas mileage without sacrificing the fun of driving. With the right model and a little research, you can walk away with a dependable, efficient ride that feels like it should have cost more.