In 2024, two of the most popular compact SUVs dueling for your attention are the Mazda CX‑5 and the Subaru Forester. Both offer stylish design, reliable performance, advanced safety, and strong resale value—but they do it in different ways. Here’s how they compare in key areas like performance, comfort, utility, reliability, and ownership cost.
1. 🔧 Powertrains & Driving Experience
Mazda CX‑5
- Equipped with a 2.5 L SkyActiv‑G 4-cylinder engine producing 187 hp and 185 lb-ft of torque
- Offers a 6-speed automatic transmission and optional 2.5 L turbo with ~250 hp on premium fuel
- Renowned for sporty handling—precise steering, firmer suspension, and confident road manners.
Subaru Forester
- Powered by a naturally aspirated 2.5 L boxer engine making 182 hp and 176 lb-ft of torque
- Comes with Subaru’s Lineartronic CVT and standard all-wheel drive.
- Prioritizes a smooth, relaxed ride over dynamic performance—perfect for daily driving.
Verdict: Go with the CX‑5 for engaging driving; choose the Forester for calm comfort and sure-footed AWD.
2. 🚗 Fuel Economy & Pricing
| Model | EPA Combined MPG | Starting MSRP |
|---|---|---|
| Mazda CX‑5 | 24 city / 30 hwy / 26 combined | $29,300 |
| Subaru Forester | 26 city / 33 hwy / 29 combined | $27,095 |
- The Forester edges ahead slightly in fuel economy and undercuts the CX‑5 on starting price by ~$2,200.
- The CX‑5’s turbo variant sacrifices some mpg (~22 combined) but adds significant power.
3. 💺 Interior & Comfort
Mazda CX‑5
- Upscale cabin with leatherette upholstery, soft-touch finishes, stitched console, heated steering wheel, and upscale design touches.
- Available power liftgate and power adjustable options.
Subaru Forester
- Spacious interior with excellent rear headroom and visibility—great for families or outdoor gear.
- Updated 11.6″ portrait touchscreen in 2024; X‑Mode off‑road aids on higher trims.
While both cabins feel premium, the CX‑5 leans more upscale, whereas the Forester offers airy space and practicality.
4. 🧰 Cargo & Utility
- Forester offers a larger cargo area and boxier shape making it more practical for camping, groceries, or sports gear.
- CX‑5 has a slightly smaller cargo hold, but still usable, especially with folding rear seats.
If you pack bikes, camp gear, or dogs regularly, the Forester’s interior offers more flexibility.
5. 🛡️ Safety & Off-Road Capability
Forester Strengths
- Standard AWD, Hill Descent Control, and dual-mode X‑Mode on higher trims en.wikipedia.org.
- IIHS Top Safety Pick in 2025; excellent ground clearance and off-road readiness en.wikipedia.org.
CX‑5 Safety
- Standard AWD on all trims, torque vectoring, and Mazda’s i-Activsense safety suite en.wikipedia.org.
- Still strong in crash testing—though may lag slightly behind Forester’s recent IIHS honors.
For ice, dirt, or adventure, the Forester is geared for light off-road. The CX‑5 delivers confident AWD on paved surfaces.
6. 🛠️ Ownership & Reliability
Mazda and Subaru share similar ownership costs and warranty coverage.
CX‑5 Benefits
- Awarded Car and Driver’s Editors’ Choice and Car and Driver 10Best in recent years.
- SkyActiv engines known for durability; straightforward maintenance.
Forester Benefits
- Legendary reliability; Boxer engine praised for longevity.
- Standard Eyesight safety system adds value and safety over time.
Expect similar reliability and upkeep for both—choose based on mechanical preference and driving environment.
7. 💵 Resale & Cost of Ownership
- Both models hold value well, thanks to high demand and brand loyalty.
- Forester may enjoy slightly better residual value in snowy or adventure markets.
- CX‑5 retains value through its luxury appeal and stylish design.
🔑 Final Verdict
Choose the Mazda CX‑5 if you:
- Want a refined, luxury-like interior
- Prefer sporty, engaging driving dynamics
- Value a turbo option for extra power
Choose the Subaru Forester if you:
- Need maximum cabin space and cargo utility
- Drive regularly in snow, mud, or light off-road
- Prefer a smooth ride with top safety credentials
Both are excellent in 2024, but the difference lies in driving style and lifestyle priorities.
🧠 FAQs
1. Which SUV is more reliable long-term?
Both Mazda and Subaru are reliable; CX‑5’s SkyActiv engines are durable, while Forester’s simple drivetrain and AWD system are proven. No clear winner here if maintained well.
2. Can the CX‑5 tow like the Forester?
Neither are heavy-duty tow vehicles—Forester can tow around 1,500 lb in base trims, while CX‑5 sticks to ~2,000 lb max with optional towing package. Forester’s towing is more oriented toward light-duty use.
3. Which one is better in snow?
The Forester has an edge thanks to higher ground clearance, Off-road X‑Mode, and superior winter traction—ideal for snowy or rugged terrain. CX‑5 AWD works well too but is more road-focused.
Both the 2024 Mazda CX‑5 and Subaru Forester shine in this category. Your choice comes down to whether you lean toward spirited, refined driving (CX‑5) or spacious, rugged practicality (Forester). Either way, you’re in for a dependable ride with plenty of features and solid resale value.